Mushman's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[(OLD)Sniper - 'Part One']

Wow! Quite good!

You've clearly put a lot of effort into this. Heck, if I started a Flash in Janurary and submitted it after 8 months (on and off like you) it'd be around as good. But I don't have that kind of commitment. :P
Great job! I really like the music. With emotional music you can really make the movie seem much more professional. I like your animation too. Great work. I'm sure you'll at least get green in the portal. Keep it up! :D

[Adventures of Harry EP:26]

Poor, just poor

You can do better than that, and you know it. You only get one star because you have some taste in music. But otherwise, I think you can't even be bothered making these showing by the effort you put into your movies. What do you plan to achieve by releasing flash movies of this quality? You won't achieve anything good, that's for sure. You should increase the quality of your movies by a lot before submitting another one. Only then will you have achieved something that is actually worthwhile because if you're going to keep submitting movies of this quality, you shouldn't submit any at all.

[This Town]

YOu pulled it off

I'd usually find stick movies quite average. But yours is good. The graphics are average, as they usually are in stick movies. Although you spent ages looking for the sound, it wasn't as good as it could've been. And humor, I don't laugh much at movies. Randoms, supossedly funny movies of low quality and crude jokes I don't find too amusing. But yours is more than that. A simple skit and you've pulled it off. Bravo. However, you other features of the movie have brought it down. But a 2 is better than a 0 mind you. And I'm known (by others and myself) to be a tight-arse. SO be happy.

[Highway Road]

Resubmission

I don't care about the fact it has a different name, one different head or a different ending colour, this movie is the same as HH3. I beat that's also the same as 2 and 1. Stop sending in your bad flash movies. Put some kind of effort in.

s0und responds:

Yes

[Fallen Heroes 2 Teaser 2]

IF you're gonna make it...

Don't waste your time on a teaser, trailer, preview or whatever. I bet com March 7th, you'll be a bit stripped for time.
Graphics are better than average are good enough. I myself don't care much for war stories. Especially Ameraican. But that's just me. I'd much rather a game of it.

Sentury responds:

I'm already half done the thing, and it is a game. I myself not being American especially considering it's about a Russian Sniper, so it's also not American.

[The Death of Jared]

The message counts

But you should try to make a Flash that is longer and, well, more touching. All I can say about your friend is, well, too bad. I guess he sucumbed to peer presure and therefore did drugs. It hurts, I know.
The graphics are Maddness style. Try perfecting your own style. That's all I can say.

[FrankThePineapple0009]

Give up

If there ever was a crap flash, this would be it. Seriously, what's the point in this? None. What does this prove? Nothing. Do you really think someone will look for this movie after judgment? No. Put some real effort into your work. Don't be another Star Syndicate. You're wasting your time. Flash isn't just stealing pics off Google Images and make them move in a movie. Do something in life that's worth doing. Because this isn't worth doing.

REVIV responds:

Hey shut up StarSyndicate is better then you.

[Pootytang Response]

I agree!

Good on you for standing up and saying your opinion in a Flash movie. I agree with every single word you said. I acctully sat there watching for a while, wondering if anything would happen. I swear it's the same as the crap AHATWI80D. That was crap. and the fact that the NG members protected it? Idiotic. You certainly did better then what he did. I gave you a 5. Remember, 5s are rare from me. You've inspired me. I want to make a Flash responce to Jerry Jackson, who's flashes are crap as. I swear, without his voice, he is nothing. Thank you for submitting. I certianly hope you can teach the idiots of the portal to put effort into their Flashes. Your graphics arn't the bast but certainly better than Pooty tang or whatever. The fact you didn't just steal pics from Google Images and download a song but drew yourself and your hat yourself and used your own voice. BTW, I like your English accent. Thanks for putting buttons and ActionScripting in so it doesn't skip ahead. All done very good. Well done. If this doesn't get through then I don't know what the Portal has came to. Keep it up!

mecha-chao responds:

I did the same thing with PA#20. I expected some kind of payoff only to result in.... NOTHING!
I find most JJ flashes to be weird. Burnt Face Man is hilarious though!
I intended the graphics to look like complete crap, if I REALLY wanted to I would have drawn alot better (or even put my real self in). But that would mean wasting more time on something that didn't really deserve it.
Im glad I used my real voice in the end. Im considering VA'ing as myself in a series about a fictional reenactment of my life...
The actionscript was an absolute B**** to work with. Flash 8 completely messes up the formatting for you. I forgot to say that SPLASH_EXE fixed the formatting for me... I should correct that in the header.
Thanx for the 5. Truely appriciated :D

[RJ - Shorts3]

Crap-e

Another random, another unfunny movie. Why do you bother? The stuff in this movie is not funny. And it's not even so bad it's funny. It's just some music with some strange lyrics that the author thought would be funny and sell as large as the Weird Al stuff but failing miserabley. Where did you find all this random music anyway? I'm surprised you found a site like that.My advice, make a decent musiv video clip. Graphics are alright and are the best part of the movie. Sound is randomly crap.

RadioactiveJesus responds:

I'm glad that you expressed yourself and thanks for leaving a review. Go watch some more mario!

[The Supanova Conflict P1]

Hmm... You've lost me

Well, you've got most of it right. Graphics and sound. But you've lost me there. Why are they at the American Supernova compertitions? It looks random to me. Try to make the storyline, more clear. Hey, it's good to know of some Australian Flash artists who acctully have talent. It's just I don't get the storyline. Still good though.